Scripture Interpretation Deviation Score (IDS)
Version 1.00
This is a preliminary concept. Needs reviews and input from US pastors
The IDS is a simple quantitative idea that can help the public know if an interpretation, scholastic view, or opinion is faulty or aligns with foundational Biblical truths. IDS also provides faith leaders with a clearer understanding of how their teachings align with core scriptural principles, encouraging them to stay grounded in foundational Christianity. Additionally, IDS allows seminary students to assess pastors and other faith leaders based on their average deviation scores.
VISION
IDS has been integrated into the hermeneutics of Scripture interpretation in Christian, Muslim, and Jewish seminaries and is utilized to assess the performance of faith leaders in interpreting Scripture
A significant challenge in Christian and Muslim hermeneutics, and across other faith traditions, is the tendency to elevate human constructs—such as culture, tradition, ideology, and political views—to a level comparable with Scripture. This can lead to complex interpretations prone to human error, which may stray from God’s Word. Such deviations affect not only extremist groups but also mainstream believers. Historical examples include the use of Scripture to justify slavery, the Curse of Ham, segregation under Jim Crow, and Manifest Destiny, which led to the forced removal of Native Americans. Today, as a global power, the United States’ influence can perpetuate such misinterpretations, impacting weaker nations, including millions of displaced Palestinians whom the U.S. has, and continues to, deny the ‘Right of Return’ to their homes for over 75 years.Root Cause: The root issue is that most scripture interpretation assessment methods currently taught in theological seminaries are entirely qualitative, making it difficult for the average Christian to distinguish sound interpretations from faulty ones presented by their local pastor. Errors by sincere faith leaders—due to oversight, cultural influences, or human error—can unintentionally lead believers toward spiritual or societal harm. To protect Christians, a straightforward and systematic approach is needed to measure and quantify possible deviations in scriptural interpretations, ensuring alignment with foundational truths.
- Compile a concise list (e.g., 10 verses) of “Foundational Scripture Verses” that reflect core Christian beliefs. Each denomination may adapt its own list.
- When assessing an interpretation, scholastic view, or opinion count how many of these Foundational Verses conflict directly with it or with its inevitable consequences.
- If the count is zero, the interpretation aligns with foundational Christian principles. If there are conflicts, it indicates a deviation, suggesting re-evaluation may be necessary.
Common Creative Legend Here
Submitted By: Visions International, Inc. Creator: Ayman Alhasan
- You can share, copy, and redistribute the material in any medium or format
- Credit must be given to the creator
- You can remix, transform, or build upon the material
- This work cannot be used for commercial purposes